defluff

The deterministic slop check for AI-generated prose. Point it at a changelog, a doc, or an agent's own output and get back the filler phrases to cut — plus a CI exit code and a pinnable score, identical on every run. No model, no API key.

Every flagged span carries no information, so cutting them loses nothing. Clean text, same tool, passes straight through:

What makes defluff worth installing over a one-off grep is the engine around the list: bring your own phrases, per-project overlays, and an MCP server your agents pick up with no wiring.

Install

pip install defluff

Or on macOS/Linux via Homebrew:

brew install ahmedak/defluff/defluff

That's it. No model download. No API key. Runs anywhere Python does.

Quick start

# Lint a file — exit 1 on slop, 0 when clean
defluff lint essay.md

# Pipe text
cat draft.md | defluff lint

# Get a bare score for scripts (0.0 – 1.0)
defluff score essay.md

# Machine-readable JSON for downstream tooling
defluff lint essay.md --json

MCP server

Exposes three tools so any MCP-aware agent can self-check prose without bespoke wiring — including its own draft, before returning it.

Zero-install via uvx (recommended) — pulls the package and the mcp extra on first run:

{
  "mcpServers": {
    "defluff": {
      "command": "uvx",
      "args": ["--from", "defluff[mcp]", "defluff-mcp"]
    }
  }
}

Or install it and run the entry point directly:

pip install "defluff[mcp]"
defluff-mcp

{
  "mcpServers": {
    "defluff": { "command": "defluff-mcp" }
  }
}

Published to the MCP Registry as io.github.ahmedak/defluff (see server.json).

mcp-name: io.github.ahmedak/defluff

Common use cases

• Agent self-correction — call slop_detect on a draft and revise the flagged phrases before returning it. Zero wiring, one session, no second model in the loop.
• CI gate on generated content — fail the build when an AI-drafted changelog or doc ships full of "furthermore" and "robust." Deterministic + exit codes + a pinnable lexicon is what an LLM-judge gate can't give you.
• Writing assistant feedback — highlight the exact phrases an editor would cut, instead of a vague "this sounds AI."
• A reward component for fine-tuning — see reward loops for caveats; on its own it's gameable.

Why defluff?

Every "AI detector" tries to classify whether text was AI-generated — a hard, unreliable problem. defluff asks a different question: does this text contain removable filler? That's deterministic, and it's true whether a human or an LLM wrote "at the end of the day."

proselint is the closest prior art — deterministic, no model — but emits yes/no warnings rather than a tunable density score, and isn't built around a list you swap, overlay, or pin.

A grep over a word list gives you raw hits. defluff gives you what you'd otherwise have to build around that list:

• An MCP server — agents self-check with zero wiring.
• Markdown- and code-aware — strips code fences, inline code, and URLs first.
• Whole-word matching — "foster" won't fire inside "fostering".
• A normalized score instead of a hit count — filler density, so one threshold works on a tweet or a 5,000-word doc.
• Overlap handling — "at the end of the day" overlapping "end of the day" counts each word once (longest-match-wins).
• Exit codes, JSON, and char-offset spans — drop into CI, pre-commit, and editor tooling.
• A pinnable lexicon hash — prove the ruler didn't move between runs.

Bring your own slop

defluff lint draft.md --lexicon team-slop.md

# team-slop.md
- circle back
- low-hanging fruit
- boil the ocean
paradigm shift

One phrase per line (# comments and -/* markers ignored). These layer on top of the built-in defaults and report under a neutral custom category. For real categories and per-phrase weights, use a .json list (see Lexicon overlays).

Ready-made domain packs

defluff lint post.md --pack marketing-growth
defluff lint post.md --pack marketing-growth,ai-llm   # stack several

List them with defluff packs. High-false-positive terms (e.g. pivot, detox) ship commented-out so they're inert until you opt in. See the packs README.

Batteries-included defaults

~130 curated patterns across five weighted categories, case-insensitive, whole-word matched:

Rhetorical patterns (beyond the list)

Some AI tells are sentence shapes, not fixed phrases — the antithesis: it's not X, it's Y, not just a list but a runtime. A regex pattern layer catches these under a rhetoric category:

Each match counts as one unit toward the score regardless of length. Turning on fragment mode changes the lexicon hash.

defluff lint draft.md                  # compound antithesis caught by default
defluff lint draft.md --pack rhetoric  # also catch the punchy "X, not Y" fragment
defluff lint draft.md --category rhetoric   # gate CI on antithesis alone

Python API

import defluff

report = defluff.detect("It is worth noting that we should leverage synergies.")
print(report.slop_score)   # 0.0 – 1.0
print(report.spans)        # flagged phrase locations + categories

score = defluff.score(text)       # bare float
clean = defluff.is_slop(text)     # bool at default threshold

lex = defluff.load_lexicon()                # pin for reproducible runs
score = defluff.score(text, lexicon=lex)

SlopReport fields:

Lexicon overlays and versioning

The bundled lexicon is the baseline; layer on top without editing the package:

# "synergy" is slop on this machine
defluff lexicon add "synergy" --category corporate --scope user

# "leverage" is fine in this repo (finance context) — commit this with the repo
defluff lexicon rm "leverage" --scope project
git add .defluff/ignore.json && git commit -m "allow 'leverage' in finance context"

• User overlay (~/.config/defluff/) — machine-wide, not committed
• Project overlay (.defluff/ at git root) — per-repo, commit it for your whole team

Writes are atomic and cross-process locked; a corrupt overlay is warned and skipped — detect() never crashes.

Every resolved lexicon (bundled + overlays + packs) carries a short content hash, printed on every run (lexicon: 2cc05ba84457) and exposed as SlopReport.lexicon_version. Pass lexicon=defluff.load_lexicon() once and every call scores against the same ruler — pinnable for CI baselines and RL rewards, and auditable since the hash changes if and only if the resolved entry set changes. Each release ships a dated lexicon with a changelog (CHANGELOG.md); ai-vocab is expected to turn over release to release, cliche/hedge/corporate/transition are near-stable.

Reading the output and setting the threshold

1. The spans — the exact filler phrases, with category. Deterministic, reliable. Act on these.
2. The score — slop_score = flagged words ÷ total, weighted by category (ai-vocab counts a little more, transition a little less). 0.20 ≈ "a fifth of this text is listed filler." Usually 0.0–1.0; can edge slightly above on text that's almost nothing but slop. Instead of being a quality quantfier, its just a tripwire that drives the CI exit code.

Pick a threshold based on how filler-dense the text is allowed to be:

The default 0.08 is provisional — hand-chosen, not yet calibrated on a labeled corpus (hence the [threshold provisional] tag). For a hard CI gate, set your own threshold and suppress your domain's vocabulary first (below).

Use in CI

Technical writing — API docs, ADRs, RFCs — legitimately uses words like robust, scalable, in order to. Suppress your project's domain vocabulary first:

bash

defluff lexicon rm "scalable" --scope project
defluff lexicon rm "in order to" --scope project
git add .defluff/ignore.json && git commit -m "defluff: allow domain vocabulary"

Then gate only on the categories you trust, not all five:

- name: Check AI-generated content for slop
  # --category ai-vocab,hedge gates only on the highest-precision categories
  run: cat generated_output.md | defluff lint --category ai-vocab,hedge --threshold 0.1

Exit code 1 fails the step, 0 passes.

Use with pre-commit

# .pre-commit-config.yaml
repos:
  - repo: local
    hooks:
      - id: defluff
        name: defluff slop check
        entry: defluff lint
        language: system
        types: [markdown]

Use in reward loops (experimental)

A deterministic, non-differentiable scalar for filler density can be a small component of a reward mix — but it's gameable alone: a model optimized purely against a fixed phrase list learns to paraphrase the filler rather than remove it. Pair it with a real quality signal (human or LLM judge); we don't yet have a published training run showing it helps.

lex = defluff.load_lexicon()  # pin once
reward = lambda text: -defluff.detect(text, lexicon=lex).slop_density  # unclamped, better gradient

delta = defluff.compare(draft_v1, draft_v2, lexicon=lex)
# {"score_a": 0.31, "score_b": 0.18, "delta": -0.13,
#  "improved": [...], "regressed": [...]}  # set diff of flagged phrases, not a semantic diff

CLI reference

defluff lint [FILE] [--json] [--threshold FLOAT] [--category CATS] [--lexicon PATH] [--pack NAMES] [--no-project-overlay]
defluff score [FILE] [--pack NAMES] [--no-project-overlay]
defluff packs          # list bundled domain packs

defluff lexicon list   [--category CATEGORY] [--scope SCOPE] [--json]
defluff lexicon add    PATTERN --category CATEGORY [--scope SCOPE] [--weight FLOAT]
defluff lexicon rm     PATTERN [--scope SCOPE]

• --category — comma-separated; only spans in those categories count toward the exit-code decision (still reports all hits). Valid: ai-vocab, cliche, hedge, corporate, transition, custom, rhetoric.
• --lexicon PATH — layers your phrases on top of the defaults. .txt/.md is one phrase per line (lands in custom); .json carries explicit categories and weights.
• --pack NAMES — comma-separated domain packs. rhetoric is reserved for the pattern pack, enabling the opt-in X, not Y antithesis fragment.

Exit codes for defluff lint: 0 = clean · 1 = slop · 2 = bad input.

Accuracy

defluff is a deterministic matcher, not a trained classifier, so the metric that matters is precision — when it flags something, is it actually removable filler? On a 50-example hand-labeled set (eval/validation.jsonl) spanning clear slop, clean prose, and jargon-as-content traps (e.g. "the robust standard errors", "pivotal trials"), at the default threshold:

Reproduce: python eval/score.py eval/validation.jsonl

Misses are novel buzzwords the lexicon hasn't seen yet (e.g. "operationalize the ideation funnel") — the known limit of a list-based matcher, not noise. Recall on listed filler is 1.00 and will rise as the lexicon grows, but won't reach 1.00 against open-ended novel jargon without a semantic layer.

Caveats: the set is small and labeled by the author — a sanity check on precision, not an independently adjudicated benchmark.

Limitations

• It matches a known list by design — it doesn't understand text. Novel buzzwords are missed; this is the trade for being deterministic, local, and reproducible (no model, no API key, pinnable hash). Pair with an LLM judge if you need semantic detection of novel filler.
• Domain jargon is contextual. "leverage" in a finance document is real content. Read the flagged spans; suppress false positives with defluff lexicon rm (adds to an ignore list, doesn't delete from the bundled lexicon).
• Span offsets are into the cleaned text. defluff strips code fences, inline code, URLs, and markdown markup before matching, so offsets won't line up with your original document — match on span.text, not raw offsets, against marked-up source.
• custom is read-only-via-file. Phrases from a --lexicon file land in custom, but defluff lexicon add --category custom is rejected — add only takes the five curated categories.
• English only in v0.
• Short texts (< 20 words) get low_confidence: true — the denominator is floored at 20 so one phrase can't read as 100% slop on a two-sentence input.

Contributing

The easiest contribution is adding a missed filler phrase:

1. Add it to src/defluff/data/lexicon-v1.json with the right category
2. pytest — smoke tests catch boundary errors
3. PR with one or two examples of the phrase in the wild

See CONTRIBUTING.md for code setup and guidelines.

License

MIT